Niagara County Sheriff's Department

Sheriff's & Undersheriff's
1808 - Present

1810-1811
Sheriff Samuel Pratt Jr.

1811-1813
Sheriff Asa Ransom

1813
Sheriff Nathan Sill

1813-1814
Sheriff Cyrinus Chapin

1814-1818
Sheriff Asa Ransom

1818-1821
Sheriff James Cronk (Col)
Undersheriff Lothrop Cooke

1821
Sheriff John Camp

1821-1822
Sheriff Lothrop Cooke

1822-1824
Sheriff Almon H. Millard
Undersheriff Lothrop Cooke

1825-1827
Sheriff Eli Bruce
Undersheriff Timothy Shaw (1825)
Undersheriff J. Goodings (1825-27)

1827-1830
Sheriff John Phillips

1831-1833
Sheriff Hiram McNeil
Undersheriff L. H. Walker

1834-1836
Sheriff George Reynale
Undersheriff Theodore Stone

1837-1839
Sheriff Tamberland T. Roberts
Undersheriff Charles S. Safford

1840-1842
Sheriff Theodore Stone
Undersheriff John Phillips

1843-1845
Sheriff James A. Cooper
Undersheriff Peter B. Aiken

1846-1848
Sheriff Franklin Spalding
Undersheriff Alva Hill

1849-1851
Sheriff Alva Hill
Undersheriff Elisha Clapp

1851-1854
Sheriff Elisha Clapp
Undersheriff Henry A. Cady

1855-1857
Sheriff Chester F. Shelley
Undersheriff William C. Beek

1858-1860
Sheriff Benjamin Farley
Undersheriff William C. Beekm

1861-1863
Sheriff George Swain
Undersheriff Jacob Farley

1864-1866
Sheriff James D. Ames
Undersheriff William C. Beekman

1867-1869
Sheriff Alfted Ransom
Undersheriff George B. Wilson
Undersheriff Fred R. Montgomery

1870-1872
Sheriff Oscar E. Mann
Undersheriff Norman 0. Allen

1873-1875
Sheriff Norman 0. Allen
Undersheriff John Merritt

1876-1878
Sheriff Joseph Batten
Undersheriff Thomas Stainthorpe

1879- 1881
Sheriff S. Clark Lewis
Undersheriff John A. Merritt
Undersheriff Frank D. Weaver

1885-1887
Sheriff George W. Batten
Undersheriff Joseph Batten

1888-1890
Sheriff Albert Pickard
Undersheriff Lawrence Pickard

1891-1893
Sheriff Nathan D. Ensign
Undersheriff William Powers
Undersheriff Chauncey Richards

1894-1896
Sheriff Patrick Tuohey
Undersheriff John F. Kenney

1897-1899
Sheriff John F. Kenney
Undersheriff Arthur Barger

1900-1902
Sheriff D. Gurney Spalding
Undersheriff Arch C. Scoby

1903-1905
Sheriff John S. Reardon
Undersheriff Wm. G. Spaldiny

1906-1908
Sheriff Thomas Eckensperger
Undersheriff Wm. G. Spalding

1909-1911
Sheriff Charles Foley
Undersheriff John H. Bollier

1912-1914
Sheriff Dennis W. Daly
Undersheriff John H. Bollier

1915-1917
Sheriff William Shaw
Undersheriff Charles A. Smith

1918-1920
Sheriff Charles A. Smith
Undersheriff J. Louis Williams

1921-1923
Sheriff Alanson C. Bigalow
Undersheriff George Hoak

1923
Sheriff Benjamin Gould
Undersheriff Lawrence J. Fell

1924-1926
Sheriff Elton L. Wille
Undersheriff James A. Campbell

1927-1929
Sheriff Jwnes A. Campbell
Undersheriff Ralph Irish

1930-1932
Sheriff Ralph Irish
Undersheriff Ira A. Cowdrick

1933-1935
Sheriff Ira A. Cowdrick
Undersheriff Robert Pearce

1936-1944
Sheriff Fred A. Bigalow
Undersheriff Orville Butler
Undersheriff Arthur Muisiner

1944-1953
Sheriff Henry Becker
Undersheriff Arthur Muisiner

1954-1957
Sheriff Arthur Muisiner
Undersheriff John Lach

1957-1970
Sheriff James K. Murphy
Undersheriff John Fitzpatrick
Undersheriff Fred Case
Undersheriff Anthony J. Villella

1971-1985
Sheriff Anthony J. Villella
Undersheriff James Faery
Undersheriff Donald E. Plant Jr.

1986-1993
Sheriff Francis L. Giles
Undersheriff Donald E. Plant Jr.

1994-PRESENT
Sheriff Thomas A. Beilein
Undersheriff Samuel J. Muscarella Jr.